????????? ??????? ? ????????????? ????? ??????? | Author : ??????? ?.?. | Abstract | Full Text | Abstract :????????: ????????? ??????? ? ????????????? ????? ??????? |
| ?????????-????????? ??????????? ?????? ??? ?????? ?????? ? ????????????? ??????? | Author : ???????? ?.?., ?????????? ?.C. | Abstract | Full Text | Abstract :????????: ?????????-????????? ??????????? ?????? ??? ?????? ?????? ? ????????????? ??????? |
| Appealing for detention in criminal proceedings: theoretical and practical aspect | Author : Tyshchenko ? | Abstract | Full Text | Abstract :The article deals with the problems of appealing for the detention in criminal proceedings on the
basis of analysis of the norms of the current criminal procedural legislation of Ukraine and judicial
practice. It is proved that the appealing for detention is actually implemented by a defense party
during the pre-trial investigation in accordance with the article 206 of the Criminal Procedure Code,
which defines general duties of a judge for the protection of human rights or during preparatory proceedings
in court |
| Sources of the penal legislation of the Austrian and Austro-?ungarian empires that were used in Ukrainian lands | Author : Berzin P | Abstract | Full Text | Abstract :The article is devoted to the review of legislative acts of the Austrian Empire and the Austro-Hungarian
Empire, which were used on Ukrainian lands in different periods of statehood. The author
analyzes the most important law provisions for the modern criminal legislation of Ukraine. Legislative
acts are divided into two groups in the article. The first group includes those that are basic and form
the so-called «basic penal law», and the second – ?additional legislative acts included in the «additional
penal law».
The purpose of this article is to systematically present the legal constructions used in the legislative
acts of the Austrian Empire and the Austro-Hungarian Empire as sources of criminal law.
The legal constructions referred to above relate to various institutions of the criminal law of the
Austrian Empire and the Austro-Hungarian Empire: a crime, an offense, a criminal responsibility, a
criminal offender, complicity in a crime, etc. Substantiated that the content of these legal structures
affected the structure of these laws as sources of criminal law. Taking into account such specificity,
the article draws attention to the structure of the Austrian Penal Code of 1803 and the structure of
this act in the wording of 1852. In particular, it is determined that Code in the edition of 1852 divided
the acts into three types: grave crimes, less serious crimes and offenses. In its separate norms, less
serious crimes and offenses were covered by the notion of «criminal act» |
| Some problems of the providing the right for defense according to the practice of European Court of Human rights | Author : Balatska O | Abstract | Full Text | Abstract :The article deals with the investigating the problems of the providing by advocate the right for
defense in criminal proceedings of Ukraine nowadays according to the judgments of European Court
of Human rights. In terms of criminal procedure proceedings reforms as a whole and advocacy institute
in particular, it appears difficult to overstate the importance and interest to a defense as a legal
institution, because its implementation enables full and comprehensive development of democracy,
equality of people, the right for defense of an accused.
The author focuses on reveling practical problems of the rights of potential suspected in the
stage of pre-trial investigation in Ukraine, negative trends of legal regulation these issues in the Criminal
Procedure Code of Ukraine. Different cases on the issue of the principle of providing the early
legal aid in judgments of European Court of Human rights are analized and author justifies some proposals
of the defining the legal status of the new subject of protection party in criminal proceedings of
Ukraine – ?the person, that really suspected in sense of the providing the right for defense. A range of
persons whose procedural rights provide for such participation, as well as the cases and conditions
for such participation, are defined.
The practice of ECHR about the principle of providing the early legal aid, free legal assistance,
the right of free choice of the defender establish legal basis for changes the ways of realization the
right to protection from suspicion in a criminal activity. The above mentioned and the practice reflected
the conclusions about drawbacks of legal determination general conditions of the realization the
right for defence and necessary changes and additions to the Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine |
| Power of the investigating judge to ensure the legality of the control over the commission of a crime | Author : Gribov M | Abstract | Full Text | Abstract :Domestic legislature included in the authority of the investigating judge the consideration of applications
by investigators or prosecutor on conducting covert investigative (search) actions and the
adoption of the relevant decisions. One of such actions is the control over the commission of a crime
(Article 271 of the CPC of Ukraine). However, unlike other covert investigative (search) actions, there
is no unequivocal requirement of the legislator regarding the issuance by the investigating judge of
the relevant decision in relation to this action. So, the CPC of Ukraine allows for the control of a crime
without the order of an investigating judge. Subject of the initiative to monitor the commission of a
crime ? the prosecutor decides whether such a decision is necessary. At the same time, the legislator
does not define the concept or the content of the control over the commission of a crime. Consequently,
this issue is subject to a clear legal regulation, for the implementation of which requires
appropriate scientific research.
The purpose of this article is to form the theoretical idea of an optimal legal structure, which
should establish the powers of an investigating judge to ensure the legality of the control over the
commission of a crime. |
| Legal structure evidence in criminal proceedings | Author : Shumylo M. Ye | Abstract | Full Text | Abstract :The question of the legal nature of evidence is complex, which is due to the complexity of its
study, perception and formation. Problem of the issue is confirmed by the unsuccessful attempt
by the legislator to divide the process of forming the evidence for the investigator and the court.
Accordance to Part 1 of Art. 84 CPC among the subjects of obtaining evidence are the investigator
and prosecutor, that indicates on the investigative method of their formation. In accordance with
the complex epistemological and legal nature of the evidence, it is not difficult to ascertain that the
investigator or prosecutor donot able to properly evaluate and verify the evidence by their own. In
addition, the inconsistency of the provisions of Part 2 of Art. 23 and Art. 84 CPC gives grounds for the
incorrect conclusion that the evidence which is obtained by the bodies of pre-trial investigation and
the evidence which is legalized by the results of the investigation in court are equable, that is the sign
of the inquisitorial type of the process. The purpose of the scientific research is to determine the legal
nature of the evidence, the order of their formation, the legal construction of evidence. Propose the
procedure for the formation of evidence, to develop approaches to the definition of the legal construction
of evidence that is based on the analysis of the legal phenomenon of evidence |
| Criminal proceedings against a particular category of persons: questions of socio-legal nature | Author : Zelenska M | Abstract | Full Text | Abstract :The article deals with the main issues concerning the socio-legal nature of criminal proceedings
concerning a particular category of persons. The provisions of the Criminal Procedural Code of
Ukraine, which contain certain contradictions on this issue, are noted.
The study of the socio-legal content of criminal proceedings provided for in Chapter 37 of the
Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine is defined for the purpose of this publication.
Historically, there are certain people in any society who, due to certain circumstances, carry out
public social functions. To ensure the fulfillment of these functions, legal measures are created and
implemented that are associated with legal immunity or immunity. The study of the problem of the
socio-legal content of the special procedure of criminal proceedings concerning a particular category
of persons is extremely relevant.
The study of the socio-legal content of criminal proceedings against a particular category of persons
is impossible without identifying the peculiarities of their legal statuses. Legislation consolidates the factors
that can influence the degree of execution of procedural obligations in the field of criminal justice.
Such factors are legal and procedural immunities and privileges. For subjects of criminal proceedings
immunities and privileges are guarantees of the proper fulfillment of the public duties assigned.
The motives behind the legislative consolidation of immunities and privileges are different. This
is mainly due to the special nature of the functions performed and the need to ensure unjustified
criminal or administrative prosecution.
Contents of Art. 10 CPC of Ukraine provides grounds for arguing that when deciding on the issue
of immunity or privileges the defining should not be the kind of occupation, but the real need for increased
legal protection of subjects that are most vulnerable to the consequences of the application
of measures of procedural coercion through age, gender, affiliation to another country or language
group, health status, pregnancy, etc.
On the basis of the analysis, an author’s vision of the nature of the proceedings for a particular category
of persons, its inalienable alignment with the categories of immunity and privileges is proposed.
The prospects for further exploration in the direction of improving the mechanism of criminal
proceedings against persons with immunities and privileges are specified |
| Powers of investigation authorities of the State Bureau of Investigations: problematic issues | Author : Pohoretskyi M., Starenkyi O | Abstract | Full Text | Abstract :The article analyzes the provisions of paragraph 9 Section XV of the Constitution of Ukraine,
paragraph 4 Section XIII of the Law of Ukraine «On Prosecutor’s Office», paragraph 1 Section X of
the CPC of Ukraine, the practice of their application is examined, on the basis of which it is concluded
that there is a certain legal conflict between them, related to the commencement of investigations
by the investigating bodies of the State Bureau of Investigations of the powers granted to them, the
presence of which adversely affects the formation of law enforcement practices and the effectiveness
of investigating crimes investigated by the bodies of the State Bureau of Investigations.
On the basis of systematic analysis of scientific and journalistic sources devoted to the problematic
issues of establishing and starting functioning of the bodies of the State Bureau of Investigations,
the provisions of the current Ukraine’s legislation and materials of law enforcement practice, possible
ways of solving the problem issues of investigations of the State Bureau of investigations of the powers
granted to them are grounded.
It is concluded that the function of the pre-trial investigation of the prosecutor’s office is temporary.
The term of its implementation ends with the commencement of the operation of the new bodies
of pre-trial investigation, which by law, depending on their jurisdiction, powers are transferred to investigate
criminal offenses. It is noted that the provisions of paragraph 9 of Section XV «Transitional
Provisions» of the Constitution of Ukraine are of a general nature and find their detailed specification
in other sectoral legislative acts.
It is indicated that the term of the prosecution authorities’ investigative powers to investigate the
crimes attributed to the investigation of the bodies of the State Bureau of Investigation expired on
November 20, 2017. Accordingly, the investigative bodies of the prosecutor’s office are deprived of
procedural authority to exercise the temporary function of pre-trial investigation given to them. The
only exception in this case is the provision of paragraph 2, paragraph 1, of Section X of the CPC of
Ukraine, the legislative capacity of the investigating authorities of the prosecutor’s office to investigate
crimes attributed to the investigations of the bodies of the State Bureau of Investigations, if they
were initiated before November 20, 2017, but not more than two years.
Taking into account that the provisions of paragraph 4 Art. 216 of the Criminal Procedure Code
of Ukraine have already come into force, and the State Investigation Bureau has not actually started
functioning as a pre-trial investigation body, and the Ukrainian criminal procedure legislation does not
regulate other entities authorized to implement these legislative provisions, suggest ways to optimize
the provisions of the current CPC of Ukraine in this part.
There is a need to change the modern paradigm of the interconnection of operational-search
activity and pre-trial investigation, provided by the Law of Ukraine «On the State Bureau of Investigations»
and the introduction of the Detective Institute in the State Bureau of Investigations. |
| Formartion of the discursive practice in the realm of the Criminal law in statehood building process of Ukraine | Author : Berezovenko A | Abstract | Full Text | Abstract :Antonina Berezovenko’s article explores pequliarities of the discourse practice development in
the realm of the criminal law as a function of the intensive statehood building process in sovereign
Ukraine. International subjectivity of Ukraine became a powerful stimulus for the development of all
discursive practices, including the special ones, in particular – ?of the discourse of the criminal law.
The appearance of such national discourse, which would be adequate for the world communicative
practice, evokes an urgent producing of those nationally specific means of a categorical – ?notional
and verbal framing of the reality, which would be capable of describing sufficiently both: national and
supranational phenomena. Under contemporary circumstances of a dominancy of English language
as an international medium
Toda’s dominancy of English as an international medium makes us to focus on research of
Ukrainian-English language encounter, pequliarities of the nomination (predominantly the terminological
one) in the comparative aspect and on the harmonization of the categorical – ?notional systems
of both languages.
The article aims to establish main tendencies of the discursive dynamics of sovereign Ukraine,
to define those factors, which influenced the formation of the discursive practice in the realm of the
criminal law, to point out important characteristics of this process in context of the establishing of
Ukraine’s subjectivity.
The contemporary discursive dynamics of Ukraine is being defined by the following tendencies:
1) intensification of linguo-creativity; 2) internationalization of linguo-creativity; 3) autochtonization
(nationalization) of linguo-creativity.
The important features of the discourse development in the realm of the criminal law after the
declaration of independence in 1991 were: 1) scientific search, significantly stimulated by Ukraine’s
international subjectivity; 2) intensive lexicographic work in this sphere of social relations (criminal
law) – ?making of dictionaries of linguistic and encyclopedic nature (Ukrainian, two- and multi-lingual);
3) creation of the manuals, which formed among the target audience such a categorical – ?notional
apparatus and communicative skills for the operations with the latter one, which would be able to play
a role of an adequate instrument for intellectual reflection of the judicial problems within sovereign
Ukraine and beyond its borders |
| Criminal responsibility for non-typical forms of attacks in the stock market by foreign law | Author : Volynets R | Abstract | Full Text | Abstract :The article analyzes the non-typical forms of encroachments on the stock market, which are
foreseen by the criminal legislation of foreign countries. The author refers to such non-typical encroachments:
influence on price setting of securities; use of false and false information to influence
the price setting of securities; abduction, destruction and damage to other securities; import of prefake
securities; illegal export of securities abroad; illegal actions with simple and transferable bills;
use of genuine or counterfeit securities for committing other crimes; failure to transfer funds to issuers
of securities; violation of the rights of participants in securities collections.
To distinguish these non-typical forms, criminal law is analyzed in the Netherlands, Denmark,
Germany, Poland, Switzerland, Sweden, Spain, Bulgaria, Uzbekistan, Azerbaijan, Kazakhstan, Georgia,
Belarus, Latvia, Estonia, Japan, China, Russia, Serbia, Tunisia.
The formulated conclusions determine non-typical forms of encroachments on the stock market,
their correlation among themselves, the significance for the content of these forms of properties of
the stock market and legal constructions. It is substantiated that the non-typical forms of encroachments
reflect the essential, most common characteristics of the attack and the damage it inflicted on
the «work» of the stock market of any country (or most of the countries with a similar stock market
system).
It is determined that the non-typical refer to the violation of the following phases of the «work»
of the stock market: associated with the exercise of the powers of the stock market participants,
depending on the form of the security (forgery, use, sale of deliberately fake securities); associated
with the process of issue (issue) of securities, their introduction into circulation and circulation; use of
insider information in the process of issue (issue) and circulation of securities. |
| Forensic theory of organization and procedural guidance to prosecutor’s pre-trial investigation: problem statement | Author : Koziakov I. | Abstract | Full Text | Abstract :In result of the constitutional reform in the area of justice, the prosecutor’s office of Ukraine
organizes and provides procedural guidance by the pre-trial investigation (part 1 article 131–1 Constitution
of Ukraine). Prosecutors perform this function. They are procedural heads of pre-trial investigation
in a particular criminal proceeding. Their activities direct at countering crime and have their
own peculiarities and patterns, which are regarded as a subject of forensic theory and
The purpose of the article is to identify the basic laws and grounds for the formation of forensic
theory of organization and procedural guidance by the prosecutor with a pre-trial investigation.
Revealed difference in the description of the activities of the prosecutor-procedural chief from
the administrative power of the head of the pre-trial investigation body on the work organization of
the investigator. It is conditioned by the public prosecutor’s powers, having criminal procedural nature
and disclosed in the supervisory and organizational-managerial aspect. The prosecutor urges
the investigator to use the methodology, techniques and tactics of investigation of crimes, use of the
whole arsenal of methods and ways of conducting investigative, secret investigative and procedural
actions. As a result of this work, the prosecutor gets the actual and the legal opportunity to form and
defend own views concerning accusation in court.
So, the function of the prosecutor in criminal proceedings objectively demonstrates the existence
of objective reasons for the formation of forensic organization theory and procedural leadership in
the investigation of crimes. They form the basis of forensic theory of organization and procedural guidance
for pre-trial investigation by the prosecutor. This area of prosecutorial activity contains many
problems. Therefore, it is necessary to scientifically substantiate theoretical issues, in particular identification
of practical and scientific prerequisites for the formation and fixing of regular trends in the
development of the organizational foundations of the work of the prosecutor-procedural chief, aimed
at ensuring the investigation of crimes and the administration of justice. Further research will contribute
to the formation of the forensic theory of the organization and prosecutor’s guidance by pre-trial
investigation, development of its concept, on the basis of which it will be possible to generalize all
available theoretical and applied achievements in this field of scientific knowledge |
| Criminal identity as an element of forensic characteristics of violation of privacy | Author : Serhieieva D., Tkach O. | Abstract | Full Text | Abstract :The article is devoted to the research of the person of the offender as an element of criminalistic
characteristic of violations of privacy of the private life. The urgency of the study of this issue is that
the person of the offender as an element of criminalistic characteristics of violations of privacy of a
private life, despite its practical significance, has not been investigated in forensic literature. The
purpose of this article is the scientific substantiation of the structure of the person of the offender as
an element of criminalistic characteristics of violations of privacy of the privacy and disclosure of its
content.
In the article, on the basis of system analysis of theoretical scientific regulations, norms of domestic
legislation and materials of investigative and judicial practice, reveals the problematic issues
regarding to the person of the offender as an element of criminalistic characteristics of violations of
privacy of a private life, formulates his concept, determines the content of this element and substantiates
its structure and correlation relations, the personality of the offender with other elements of
criminalistic characteristics of violations of privacy of the private life. It turns out that the system of
information about the perpetrator’s personality allows not only to correctly classify a criminal offense
committed, but also significantly improves the effectiveness of the process of promoting versions and
planning of the investigation, the choice of tactical methods for conducting procedural actions and
investigations in general.
It is concluded that the person of the offender as an element of forensic characteristics is a collection
of information about physical, social, moral and psychological and other features and properties
characteristic of persons who committed a criminal offense of a certain type.
The offender is a person who is unauthorized to collect, store, use, destroy, distribute and modify
information about the private life of another person, who is the confidential information about this
person, in the course of violations of privacy.
The summarized data on the identity of the offender as an element of criminalistic characterization
of violations of privacy of the private life and their correlation with other elements of forensic
characteristics are established. |
| Features of the beginning of criminal proceedings and circumstances that are established in the investigation of official negligence | Author : Toporetska Z | Abstract | Full Text | Abstract :In the article, based on the analysis of scientific literature on criminalistics and criminal process
practical materials, the problematic issues of the initiation of criminal proceedings and the determination
of a range of circumstances that are established in the investigation of the facts of official
negligence are analyzed.
The purpose of this article is to study the peculiarities of the initiation of criminal proceedings and
determine the range of circumstances that are established in the investigation of official negligence.
Often, law enforcement agencies receive information about the facts of official negligence from
information in the media about an event: an accident, a fire, pollution of the territory, etc. Criminal proceedings
usually begin after inspecting the place of the event (the place where the socially dangerous
consequences of official negligence have occurred). Oral or written statements (reports) about the
commission of this crime are filed on the results of revision or official inspections.
The largest group of circumstances that are established in the investigation of official negligence
is the occurrence of a criminal offense. Establish: who, when and in what circumstances reported
about the fact of negligence; description of the body where the official is employed; description of
the position and powers of an official; analysis of decisions taken by the official, actions taken in the
particular case; whether they belong to official duties, the failure to fulfill which resulted in official
negligence; what actions the person was obligated to commit, and in what manner and why did not
do it etc.
In addition, such circumstances are established during the investigation: the person guilty in the
commission of negligence, the type and amount of crime damage; mitigating and aggravating circumstances,
grounds for exemption from criminal liability or punishment etc.
The correct establishment of the range of circumstances that are established in criminal proceedings
in the investigation of official negligence allow the investigator to properly organize and plan
investigations, achieve the goal and fulfill the objectives of the criminal proceedings specified in Art.
2 CPC of Ukraine |
| Guarantees of the rights of minors in criminal proceedings during interrogation | Author : Vidyuk A | Abstract | Full Text | Abstract :The urgency of the topic of research is predetermined be involvement of a significant number of
minors in the field of criminal justice, where their rights may be violated as a result of unfair or unprofessional
exercise of their powers by representatives of the judiciary.
The purpose of the article is to study the procedural rights and guarantees of minors in criminal
proceedings during interrogation and to develop, on the basis of their analysis, proposals for the
improvement of these procedural rights and guarantees, taking into account the age-old features of
minors.
The article analyzes the international treaties to which the state of Ukraine is a party, which establishes
additional guarantees of the observance of the rights of minors in the field of criminal justice,
analyzed the norms of the current CPC, which establishes special rules for interrogation of minors,
and developed reasonable proposals in order to improve the relevant provisions of the CPC.
As a result of scientific research, it has been established that the procedural guarantees of a
minor during interrogation should not extend to persons who have not attained the age of 18 but who
have acquired full civil capacity, concluded that it is necessary to clarify the procedural status of a
teacher, a psychologist, a physician who is involved in the interrogation of a minor and the specialization
of investigators, prosecutors conducting criminal proceedings against juveniles.
It is proposed to clarify the procedural status and to establish requirements for a psychologist,
teacher and doctor involved in interrogation of minors, as well as to improve the provisions of the current
legislation of Ukraine, which regulate the procedural status of specially authorized investigators,
prosecutors in criminal proceedings against juveniles, etc.
The necessity of further implementation of the norms of international law in the national legislation
of Ukraine in the juvenile justice sphere, including the implementation of the relevant provisions
of the Council of Europe Convention on the Protection of Children against Sexual Exploitation and
Sexual Abuse in order to ensure the effective implementation of criminal proceedings against minors
is given. |
| In search of justice for victims of international crimes: Ukraine and the International Criminal Court | Author : Gacka P | Abstract | Full Text | Abstract :This article is devoted to an analysis of the status of victims of international crimes in international
criminal law with particular reference to those victims who have been harmed in different regions
of Ukraine (Kyiv, Crimea, Eastern Ukraine) since 21 November 2013. In other words, the author
conducts a concise analysis of who can qualify as a victim of international crimes as well as of what
set of rights such a victim possesses in proceedings before the International Criminal Court (ICC).
These general remarks, in turn, are subsequently situated in the wider perspective of the so-called
Ukrainian case.
It is argued that for a long time victims of international crimes have been forgotten subjects of
international criminal trials. The situation has only changed gradually with the development of international
criminal law since the Nuremberg trials until 1998 when the Rome Statute of the International
Criminal Court (ICC) was adopted. Nowadays, victims’ procedural rights are expanding as, in fact,
are definitions of victimhood provided for in various international legal documents (i.?e. definition of
victims of crime included in rule 85 of the Rules of Procedure and Evidence of the ICC). It follows
that both natural persons and legal persons can qualify as victims of crime in proceedings before the
International Criminal Court. Apart from that, also the concept of an international crime is subject to
certain controversies which cannot be solved by a mere reference to legal definitions or texts. Therefore,
it is argued that international crimes should be differentiated from ordinary offences due to their
different normative source and the specific context of the commission of these crimes. Moreover, the
author also criticizes non-legal (moral) justifications underlying the differentiation between international
and ordinary crimes. In part IV, in turn, the current status of the ’Ukrainian situation’ before the
International Criminal Court is examined. The author concludes the substantive part with cataloguing
the list of procedural rights that victims of international crimes have been equipped with together with
the adoption of the ICC’s Rome Statute and which, potentially, can be acquired by victims of international
crimes that have been committed during the Ukrainian crisis |
| ???????? ???????? ???? ?????????????? ?????????? ?????? ?????? 36 ?? 284 ????????????? ?????????????? ??????? ???????, ?????????? ? ????? ????????? ????????? ?????????? ?????????? ???? ??? 27.02.2018 | Author : ?????? ?.?., ??????????? ?.?., ?????????? ?.C. | Abstract | Full Text | Abstract :? ????? ?? ???????? ????????? ????????? ?????????? ?????????? ???? ?. ????????????? ??? 27 ?????? 2018 ?. ?????????? ???????? ?????? ???????????? ?????????? ???????? ?????? 36 ?? 284 ????????????? ?????????????? ??????? ??????? (???? – ??? ???????) ? ??????? ???????????? ??????????? ???????? ? ????????? ?? ????????? ??????? ??? ???????? ????????????? ??????????? |
| Legitimacy of the use of hypnosis during interrogations of victims and witnesses and the processual value of the information obtained from its results | Author : Dankevych M | Abstract | Full Text | Abstract :For the purpose of the effectiveness, completeness and quickness of investigations of crimes,
scientists and practitioners have increasingly drawn their attention to the possibility of applying hypnosis
to the pre-trial investigation stage as one of the non-traditional method for obtaining significant
information for criminal proceedings. However, there is no single point of view regarding the legality
and appropriateness of its application.
Therefore, the purpose of the article is to analyze and generalize existing scientific approaches
to the legality of the use of hypnosis during the interrogation of victims and witnesses and to establish
the procedural significance of information obtained with its results.
On the basis of the analysis of the current criminal procedural legislation of Ukraine, scientific
sources and experience of foreign states, the author defined the concept of non-traditional methods
of proof and hypnosis. The experience of applying hypnosis during the investigation of criminal violations
in foreign countries has been analyzed and described.
The article analyzes the views of scientists who oppose the use of hypnosis during the investigation,
as well as the views of authors who believe that using such non-traditional method of crime
investigations is advisable.
The author established that the use of hypnosis in the investigation of crimes should meet certain
conditions that do not contradict the current legislation and do not violate the rights and freedom of
citizens. The borders of admission of application of hypnosis are marked. The attention is drawn to
the fact that the use of hypnosis is appropriate when interrogating witnesses and victims who have
been affected by psychological or physical influence during the commission of a crime. It was found
that the use of hypnosis is possible in those cases where the interrogated person for various reasons
can not remember the circumstances of the crime.
The article analyzes the opinions of scientists about the possibility of using information obtained
through the use of hypnosis. It is determined that such data are not have value of evidence. |
| Criminalization of domestic violence – ?criminal legislation novelties of Ukraine | Author : Zaporozhets A | Abstract | Full Text | Abstract :The article is devoted to changes in Criminal Code of Ukraine in a part of criminalization of
certain acts of domestic violence, in connection with adoption by The Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine
modifications to the Criminal and Criminal Procedural Codes for the Prevention of Violence against
Women and Domestic Violence. The above modifications contribute in preventing and combating
matters against violence, and bringing it into line with the provisions of the Istanbul Convention. The
violence in which victim suffered has an impact on various aspects of their lives, therefore it means
that they need legally guaranteed security guarantees.
Our focus is on analysis of article 126–1 Criminal Code of Ukraine. The specified offence have
been researched through the separate elements of its actus reus. First and foremost uncovered the
physical violence, economic violence, mental violence and psychological violence as ways of committing
the offence and its legal signs. Physical violence was also examined and it was emphasized
on the lack of its terminological consolidation.The law provides justification for the expediency of
changing the term «psychological» violence to «physical» violence. The third type of violence that
was studied is economic violence. Based on an analysis of the opinions of scientists and signs of this
type of violence as a criminal law category, the authors proposed the definition of economic violence
and its attachment in the note to Article 126–1 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine. According to analysis
of article 126–1 Criminal Code of Ukraine considered signs of a special subject. Analyzing the rule
in question, the authors drew attention to the allocation which made lawmakers, namely, a separate
group of special subjects. Such an innovation did not find its justification in the analysis of the criminal
law conducted by the authors and in view of this, such an element of the crime is considered as an
objective sign, namely the particular state of dependence of the victim on the perpetrator. All in all
its innovation would tend to the echo that of existing legal instruments. We can see than, that for his
analysis be useful to refer to the legislation of other branches of the law |
| Monitoring of bank accounts as covert investigative (detective) action: problems of legislative regulation andpractical implementation and ways to solve them | Author : Iveruk N | Abstract | Full Text | Abstract :The article is dedicated to legislative attachment of monitoring of bank accounts as covert investigative
(detective) action. Scientific researches of monitoring of bank accounts as covert investigative
(detective) action are very important because of their value for both theory and practice. This matter
isn’t investigated enough because of its innovation in the criminal procedural law since 2015.
The article examines concept and content of information, that can be determined as bank secrecy,
occasions when this information can be outspread. The author pays attention to the grounds of
application, which are exhaustive and established in Criminal Procedural Code.
Having examined legislature, the list of subjects, who can conduct this covert investigative (detective)
action, is determined. The author make a suggestion to give authority to other subjects with
the aim to provide objectivity and neutrality during criminal procedure.
Analyzing the legislature, procedure of conducting monitoring of bank accounts as covert investigative
(detective) action is clarified, basic requirements to pleading and award are defined, period
of conducting this covert investigative (detective) action is appointed. The article also indicates problems
of application of monitoring of bank accounts in practice, for example, high price of conducting
this action, necessity of additional staff and lectures, and so on.
The aim of the research is to find out the importance and essentiality of monitoring of bank accounts
as covert investigative (detective) action in theory and practice, that will promote implementing
of tasks of criminal procedure, effective investigation of crimes, identifying problems, developing
proposals and recommendations for their solution.
The specifics of the criminal procedural activities require the improvement of criminal procedural
law. While analyzing scientific researches the author clarified the necessity of making changes to
criminal procedural legislation, in particular to expanse the list of subjects, who can conduct this covert
investigative (detective) action, to form legal certainty of the procedure and the procedural form
of fixing revealed evidences.
Having examined theoretical and practical aspects of the monitoring of bank accounts, the author
comes to the conclusion that the prospects are seen in the development of proposals for the adoption
of world experience, compliance with international legal standards, etc. Monitoring of bank accounts
as any other covert investigative (detective) action must have clear and detailed legislative regulation,
with compliance of principles of legal certainty and proportionality |
| International standards for supporting the public prosecution in trial | Author : Lysachenko Y | Abstract | Full Text | Abstract :The Strategy for the Reform of the Judiciary, the Judiciary and Related Legal Institutions for
2015–2020 points out that the main task of reforming the prosecutor’s offices is further optimizing
the powers of the prosecutor’s office and limiting their scope in line with the recommendations of
the Council of Europe and, as a consequence, bringing the prosecutor’s office in line with European
standards. Therefore, the investigation of international standards in the field of criminal justice is a
prerequisite for the development and improvement of domestic theoretical and legal principles of
criminal prosecution of the prosecutor, in particular, for maintaining public prosecution in trial.
The purpose of this article is to determine the international standards of prosecuting public prosecution
in trial.
International standards for supporting the public prosecution in trial determine the requirements,
which are contained in the international documents, customs and practice of international judicial
bodies on the basic provisions of the legal status of the prosecutor while maintaining a public prosecution
in trial. These standards include: 1) ensuring the independence of the prosecutor; 2) observance
of human rights while maintaining public prosecution; 3) implementing the principles of speed,
efficiency and impartiality; 4) ensuring the security of prosecutors; 5) the impossibility of forming a
prosecution on evidence that does not meet the admissibility criterion; 6) adherence to the rules of
professional conduct.
As a result of the investigation, we conclude that there is an urgent need to improve the domestic
legislation in line with international standards, which will increase the efficiency of public prosecutors’
functions of maintaining a public prosecution in trial and protecting human and citizens’ rights and
freedoms. The author proposes to define and legally consolidate the definition of «international standard»
and exclude from the CPC of Ukraine Article 341. |
| ????????? ??????????? ??????? ???????????-???????? ??????? ????????? ????? | Author : ?????? ?.?. | Abstract | Full Text | Abstract :????????: ????????? ??????????? ??????? ???????????-???????? ??????? ????????? ????? |
| ???????? ???????? ? ????? ???????????? ????????????? ?????? ???????????? ????????????: ????????? ??????????? ??????? ?????? ?? ???????? | Author : ???????? ?.?. | Abstract | Full Text | Abstract :????????: ???????? ???????? ? ????? ???????????? ????????????? ?????? ???????????? ????????????: ????????? ??????????? ??????? ?????? ?? ???????? |
| . Functional structure of pre-trial investigation in the criminal process of France and Ukraine (comparative legal research) | Author : Mykhailiuk A. | Abstract | Full Text | Abstract :The article is devoted to comparative and legal research of models of pre-trial investigation of
France and Ukraine. The current model of pre-trial investigation in Ukraine continues to show its
inadequate efficiency in determining the actual circumstances of the case, impartial investigation,
numerous violations of human rights and citizen. The purpose of this article is to develop further proposals
to create a real, efficient, economic model of pre-trial investigation in guaranteeing of human
and civil rights and freedoms in Ukraine.
This article describes and compares the powers of judicial police France during inquests and operative
units of Ukraine. Making a comparative analysis of powers in the field of operational subdivisions
of Ukraine and governmental inquests France be traced a certain resemblance between them.
However, it is made a conclusion that the judicial police France has more rights during inquests,
unlike the operative units of Ukraine. In addition, are considered and compares the powers of public
prosecutor offices France and Ukraine. In addition, the powers of the prosecutor’s office of France
and Ukraine are reviewed and compared. It is concluded that the Office of the Prosecutor’s Office
of Ukraine is simultaneously entrusted with the authority to organize, supervise, conduct pre-trial
investigation, as well as form and maintain a prosecution in court, which testifies to the inconsistency
and incompatibility of the procedural powers of the prosecutor’s office in Ukraine. In contrast to the
French investigating magistrate, it is possible to point out that, unlike the Ukrainian investigator, he is
an uninterested objective arbiter, whereas the investigator in Ukraine, has been charged to the party
of charges and is characterized by an indictment of authority.
The main drawback of pre-trial investigation in Ukraine should be regarded as his accusatory line
with a combination of incompatible functions investigator for investigating accusations and protection.
Submitted a proposal on the necessity of creating an independent, impartial trial investigation of his
belonging to the court, depriving the prosecutor’s office of the procedural guidance for the pre-trial.
investigation. Operational-search activity, which was inherited from the Soviet model of pre-trial investigation,
should be eliminated with the further creation of a single police inquiry under the direction
of the prosecutor’s office |
| Terms of pre-trial investigation | Author : Khrystenko K | Abstract | Full Text | Abstract :The article deals with the issue of implementation of the terms of pre-trial investigation, according
to the analysis of scientific sources devoted to the terms of criminal proceedings, materials of law
enforcement activities. The author analyses the provisions of the Law of Ukraine «On Introduction of
Amendments to the Commercial Procedure Code of Ukraine, Civil Procedure Code of Ukraine, Administrative
Court Procedure Code of Ukraine and Other Enactments dated 03.10.2017 No. 2147-VIII
(Law No.2147-VIII). The domestic legislator conceptually changed the terms of pre-trial investigation
and the procedural procedure for their calculation under this law.
The purpose of this article is to investigate the current legislation changes to the Article 219 of the
Criminal Procedural Code (CPC) of Ukraine, according to the adopted law of Ukraine «On Introduction
of Amendments to the Commercial Procedure Code of Ukraine, Civil Procedure Code of Ukraine,
Administrative Court Procedure Code of Ukraine and Other Enactments dated 03.10.2017 No. 2147-
VIII (Law No.2147-VIII) and to reveal their shortcomings and providing suggestions on optimizing the
provisions of the current CPC of Ukraine in this part.
In the article, the author defines the pre-trial investigation term and its meaning, in accordance
with the latest amendments to the Criminal Procedural Code of Ukraine.
The author analyzes the new ground for the closure of criminal proceedings – ?if a new term of
pre-trial investigation (6–18 months) has expired – ?except in the case when the person was informed
about the suspicion of committing a serious or especially grave crime against human life and health
In order to improve the Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine, in order to ensure a prompt, complete
and unimpeded investigation and court proceedings, it is proposed to amend the Criminal Procedural
Code of Ukraine regarding the procedural procedure for calculating the terms of pre-trial investigation,
in particular, from the moment of registering a criminal proceeding in the Unified Register
of Pre-trial Investigations (URPI), by the day of referral to a court with an indictment, a petition for the
use of compulsory measures of a medical or educational nature, a petition for a link ting from criminal
individual responsibility or the day the decision to close the criminal proceedings |
| Features of attracting a specialist at the initial stage of the investigation of robbery committed with the home invasion | Author : Shulga J. | Abstract | Full Text | Abstract :The article researches the problematic issues of attracting a specialist at the initial stage of the
investigation of robbery committed with the penetration into the house. The tactical and organizational
issues that arise in the investigator during the involvement of a specialist during the investigation
are considered.
The author analyzes the theory and practice of attracting a specialist for carrying out separate
investigatory actions at the initial stage of investigation of robbery. The article formulates scientificpractical
recommendations on the use of special knowledge in the process of investigation.
At the initial stage of the investigation of robbery, in most cases there is a need to attract specialists
from different profiles, both legal and non-legal, who have special knowledge on particular issues
that arise during the investigation. Such specialists, as a rule, are criminologists, cynologists with an
official dog, biologists, chemists, forensic physicians, psychologists and others.
It should be noted that the current legislation also lacks a clear definition of the concept of special
knowledge. In some normative documents, the concept of special knowledge is used in the regulation
of the conditions for carrying out certain types of expert research, where there is a need for the
application of narrow professional knowledge. As a result, there is a debate about the definition of
this concept in scientific circles.
Effective investigation of robbery committed with housing penetration is impossible without the
participation of specialists. Taking into account the specifics of robbery with penetration into the
home, it should be noted that at the initial stage of the investigation of this crime there is a need for
attracting specialists from different profiles, namely, forensic, ballistic, chemical, biological, forensic,
medical and others. |
|
|